Squarespace vs Big Cartel

Squarespace vs Big Cartel

Choosing the right platform to launch a website is crucial for the success of e-commerce and online stores. Both Squarespace and Big Cartel offer unique features tailored to different types of sellers, which might make it difficult to decide which one suits your business needs better.

In this post, let's venture into the features of Squarespace versus Big Cartel, helping you understand which platform could enhance your E-Commerce experience and streamline your online store's operations. Whether you're just starting out or looking to switch platforms, this comparison aims to provide clear insights to guide your decision.

Squarespace: Comprehensive Web Design and Commerce

Squarespace offers a robust platform for individuals and businesses looking to create professional websites with an emphasis on design and functionality. Known for its sleek templates and intuitive drag-and-drop interface, Squarespace allows users to craft aesthetically pleasing sites without the need for coding skills.

The platform supports a wide range of uses, from personal blogs to comprehensive e-commerce solutions, making it a popular choice for photographers, artists, and entrepreneurs.

Squarespace's e-commerce capabilities are particularly notable. The platform provides extensive tools for managing inventory, processing payments, and handling shipping logistics, all integrated into user-friendly website designs.

Additionally, Squarespace offers built-in analytics tools that help users track visitor behavior and sales trends, which can be critical for growing an online business.

Big Cartel: A Niche for Creatives and Small Retailers

Big Cartel stands out as a straightforward platform tailored specifically for artists and small-scale retailers. Unlike Squarespace, which caters to a wide range of business types, Big Cartel focuses on simplicity and ease of use for creators who want to sell their work directly to consumers.

The platform supports a variety of independent ventures, from fashion designers and jewelry makers to painters and photographers.

One of Big Cartel’s strengths is its affordability and scalability. The platform offers a free plan for sellers with a small number of products, making it accessible to new artists and entrepreneurs testing the market.

As businesses grow, Big Cartel provides more extensive plans that still prioritize cost-effectiveness. Moreover, Big Cartel places a high value on customizability, allowing users to modify their store's appearance even with limited technical knowledge, though its design options are generally considered less sophisticated than those of Squarespace.

Squarespace vs Big Cartel - Big Cartel Logo

Both Squarespace and Big Cartel provide valuable tools for building and managing online stores, they cater to distinctly different audiences. Squarespace offers a more comprehensive set of features suited to a diverse array of businesses and individuals seeking a blend of elegance and functionality.

In contrast, Big Cartel serves as an ideal platform for creatives and small retailers looking for an uncomplicated and affordable way to enter the e-commerce space.

Pricing Structures: Squarespace vs Big Cartel

Platform Plan Name Price Per Month (Billed Annually) Price Per Month (Billed Monthly) Features
Squarespace Personal $16/month (Save 30% annually) $23month Foundational plan with access to fully customizable, best-in-class templates
  Business $23/month (Save 30% annually) $33/month Ideal for those looking to grow their audience and begin taking payments
  Commerce Basic $27/month (Save 25% annually) $36/month Designed for individuals and businesses looking to sell products or services online. This plan includes a range of features tailored to help users easily manage and grow their online store with no transaction fees.
  Commerce Advanced $49/month (Save 24% annually) $65/month Designed to cater to the needs of more experienced sellers who are looking for a comprehensive set of tools to manage and expand their online stores with no transaction fees.
Big Cartel Gold (Forever Free) $0 $0 The basics of everything you need to sell online and in-person.
  Platinum $12 ( Save 20%) $15 For a growing business with more inventory and shipments to manage.
  Diamond $24 ( Save 20%) $30 The support you need for your scaling business with over 50 products ready to go.

Key Points:

Squarespace offers a range of plans from basic website capabilities to advanced e-commerce options. The pricing scales with the level of features provided, making it suitable for businesses at various growth stages.

Big Cartel targets smaller vendors or artists with a simpler pricing model. The free tier is particularly attractive for those just starting out, with modest upgrades available for expanding product listings and customization options.

This table showcases the direct monthly costs associated with each plan and highlights the differences in features and scalability between Squarespace and Big Cartel. This information can be crucial for potential users to consider what best fits their needs and budget constraints.

Comparing Features: Squarespace vs Big Cartel

When evaluating the features of Squarespace and Big Cartel, potential users will find distinctions in functionality that cater to different needs, particularly in website aesthetics, e-commerce capabilities, and user interface.

Squarespace vs Big Cartel - Squarespace interface

Website Design and Aesthetics

Squarespace is renowned for its visually appealing templates and sophisticated design options. It offers a wide range of customizable templates that are well-suited for artists, photographers, and businesses looking to create professional-looking websites.

In contrast, Big Cartel focuses more on simplicity and ease of use, with fewer templates that are nonetheless effective for setting up a store quickly. The templates in Big Cartel are more tailored to independent artists and makers.

E-commerce Capabilities

In terms of e-commerce functionality, Squarespace provides a robust platform suitable for businesses of varying sizes. It supports an extensive array of products and services, comprehensive inventory management, multiple payment gateways, and advanced shipping options.

Big Cartel, on the other hand, is designed for smaller retailers and offers basic e-commerce tools that are easier to manage but may not scale as well for larger operations. Big Cartel limits the number of products users can sell, which can be a significant consideration for growing businesses.

User Interface and Experience

Squarespace offers a more dynamic editing interface, which, while feature-rich, might require a steeper learning curve for new users. It provides detailed analytics and marketing tools that can enhance a website’s reach and efficiency.

Big Cartel’s interface is more straightforward, focusing on ease of use and quick setup, which may appeal to those who prefer a less complex system for managing their online store.

The choice between Squarespace and Big Cartel should be based on the specific needs of the user. Squarespace is ideal for those requiring a high level of design customization and extensive e-commerce features, while Big Cartel may be better suited for artists and small retailers who need a simpler, more direct approach to online selling.

Squarespace vs Big Cartel -  digital illustration of a person thinking about

Making the Right Choice: When to Opt for Squarespace or Big Cartel

Deciding between Squarespace and Big Cartel hinges on understanding the core needs of your business and your role in the marketplace. Each platform offers unique advantages tailored to specific business models, making it essential to align your choice with your long-term goals and operational needs.

Target Audience and Product Volume

If your business involves a higher volume of products or requires a sophisticated presentation, Squarespace is likely the more appropriate choice. Its ability to handle diverse and extensive product lines with a high degree of customization supports businesses poised for growth or those already operating at scale.

Conversely, Big Cartel is optimized for smaller scale operations, particularly suitable for artists and creatives who manage a limited inventory and prefer a platform that’s straightforward and easy to set up.

Design and Branding Requirements

For businesses that rely heavily on branding and design, Squarespace provides superior design tools and template options that enhance the visual appeal of your site. This is particularly beneficial for industries where customer impression and site aesthetics are pivotal to business success, such as photography, art, and high-end retail.

Big Cartel, while offering less complexity in design, may be the right fit for those who value simplicity and ease of use over elaborate design capabilities.

Budget Considerations

Budget constraints are another critical factor. Big Cartel’s free plan for small inventories and lower-cost plans make it an attractive option for new entrepreneurs or artists making their first foray into online selling. The financial commitment required to start on Big Cartel is minimal, allowing users to invest more in other areas such as product development or marketing.

On the other hand, Squarespace, with its more robust e-commerce tools and advanced features, requires a higher initial investment, justified by its comprehensive capabilities that could support larger business operations more effectively.

Technical Skills and Resources

The level of technical skill available within your team can also influence the decision. Squarespace offers a dynamic platform that, while user-friendly, has a steeper learning curve due to its rich array of features and customization options. Businesses with the capacity to harness these capabilities, either through in-house talent or external support, will find Squarespace to be a powerful tool.

For those who prefer minimal technical involvement, Big Cartel’s ease of use ensures that you can manage your online store without needing extensive technical knowledge or resources.

By carefully considering these factors—audience, product volume, design needs, budget, and technical skills—you can make a well-informed decision between Squarespace and Big Cartel. Each platform serves distinct types of businesses excellently; the key is to choose one that aligns best with your specific business model and growth aspirations.

Conclusion: Squarespace vs Big Cartel

The choice between Squarespace and Big Cartel ultimately depends on the unique needs and circumstances of your business. Squarespace, with its robust features and sophisticated design options, is ideal for businesses that require a comprehensive e-commerce solution and have a larger product volume. Its advanced tools for inventory management, payment processing, and shipping logistics make it a powerful platform for growth-oriented businesses.

On the other hand, Big Cartel's simplicity and affordability make it a great choice for small-scale creatives and retailers who are just starting out or operate with a limited inventory. Its user-friendly interface and focus on customizability allow artists and makers to easily set up and manage their online stores.

By understanding the distinct offerings and strengths of each platform, you can select the one that best aligns with your business strategy, ensuring your online presence is both effective and aligned with your growth goals.

Keep Reading

* Read the rest of the post and open up an offer